Explainer: How strong are the banks in India as compared to America, how safe is the public’s money


New Delhi: Final Friday, when the closure of America’s largest Silicon Valley Financial institution (SVB) was introduced, there was chaos among the many startup corporations of India. The rationale for this was that many of the world’s startups together with India have opened their accounts in Silicon Valley Financial institution and billions of {dollars} are deposited in these accounts. Of this, about $250,000 is an quantity that isn’t insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Company (FDIC). Due to this fact, because of the closure of Silicon Valley Financial institution, the startup corporations of India noticed their cash sinking and in a rush, in addition they tried to withdraw their deposits.

Proper now the US authorities and the central financial institution had been making efforts to take care of this disaster that on final Sunday one other signature financial institution was additionally closed. After the closure of two large banks of America inside per week, questions are additionally arising that how robust is India’s banking system as in comparison with America and the way secure is the hard-earned cash of the general public within the banks right here? Come, let’s know the solutions to those questions…

Classes from the 2008 Recession Rescue Plan

In keeping with a media report, final Friday the world got here to know that the 40-year-old Silicon Valley Financial institution of America shall be working beneath the receivership of the Federal Deposit Insurance Company (FDIC). The story of the California-based lender’s collapse was fabricated in lower than two days. Nevertheless, on Monday, there was reduction information for the depositors of Silicon Valley Financial institution, when the US Treasury, Federal Reserve, FDIC and Joe Biden administration introduced a rescue plan to soundly return the general public’s cash deposited within the financial institution.

The three companies (US Treasury, Federal Reserve and FDIC) mentioned of their joint assertion that each one Silicon Valley financial institution depositors (solely these non-insured by the FDIC) could have entry to their funds from Monday and taxpayers won’t undergo any loss. . Defending the financial institution’s depositors, the US authorities additionally introduced the closure of the New York-based Signature Financial institution, assuring its depositors that their deposits could be made absolutely obtainable for withdrawal if mandatory. The Fed additionally introduced a $25 billion backstop for banks that did not pay their depositors. This step was taken by these three companies as a lesson of 2008 recession.

$465 billion misplaced in international monetary shares

If media reviews are to be believed, the steps taken by the federal government and three monetary companies to offer reduction to the depositors after the closure of Silicon Valley Financial institution was a fast motion to bail out the financial institution from the disaster. Whereas immediate motion was taken by the highest US establishments, applicable assurance was additionally given to the depositors. The US President additionally condemned these answerable for the ‘mess’ at SVB Financial institution, vowing to take them to job, together with a regulatory mechanism working in the direction of defending deposits. One of these motion was additionally wanted as a result of buyers world wide had been falling quick on banks of their respective geographies because of the collapse of America’s sixteenth largest financial institution. World monetary shares misplaced $465 billion within the wake of the Silicon Valley Financial institution monetary disaster as of Monday, in keeping with Bloomberg.

What’s the situation of banks in India

It’s mentioned that the banking system is a system the place panic spreads quicker than most regulators. Fast response is important to take care of public confidence within the banking system. On this sense, there are some classes from the Silicon Valley episode that may work very nicely in India. If we speak about India’s banking system, until February 21, 2023, there have been about 2,029 banks in India, the place deposits had been insured. These embody public sector banks, personal sector banks, overseas banks, native space banks, regional rural banks and cooperative banks.

How secure is the deposit in Indian banks

In keeping with a media report, out of the full deposits of Rs 165 lakh crore in these banks until March 31, Rs 81 lakh crore was insured by the Deposit Insurance and Credit Assure Company. As compared, the DICGC had a fund of Rs 1.47 lakh crore, whereas the deposits lined beneath this insurance coverage scheme is just 46 per cent of the full deposits and the protection is 98 per cent by the variety of depositors’ accounts. The primary distinction in Sankalp comes out in the best way regulatory and different companies function in India.

Depositors’ entry to cash in India

It didn’t take US companies even per week to offer full entry to the depositors of Silicon Valley Financial institution. What’s the state of affairs in India? The DICGC process states that depositors of a liquidated or reconstructed financial institution could have entry to insured deposits of as much as Rs 5 lakh per depositor inside two months of receiving a declare from the depositor. Entry to any deposits in extra of the insured quantity relies on the kind of financial institution’s decision. Particular timelines for deposit funds had been formalized solely in 2021 when the federal government amended the DICGC Act, however the actuality of well timed funds isn’t the identical for all lenders.

No lesson even from Punjab & Maharashtra Financial institution and Sure Financial institution case

Within the Sure Financial institution rescue plan of March 2020, depositors needed to look ahead to a few fortnight earlier than accessing their funds. A consortium of monetary establishments supported the personal lender with fairness infusion, whereas the Reserve Financial institution of India supplied an emergency liquidity window of Rs 50,000 crore to make funds to depositors. When it got here to Punjab & Maharashtra Financial institution, which went bankrupt in 2019, the withdrawal delay was even longer. After banning deposit withdrawals in September 2019, the regulator got here out with a draft decision plan in November 2021, which was finalized solely in January 2022. Solely then had been depositors in a position to entry their absolutely insured deposits of as much as Rs.5 lakh. The compensation plan for big depositors guarantees a ten yr lengthy compensation tenure.

Why depositors in India have to attend

Can DICGC be made to maneuver quicker than this? Clearly as soon as the RBI has taken steps to reconstruct a industrial or co-operative financial institution or to place it beneath some regulatory stringency, it’s inconceivable why the insured depositors want to attend. That too in an period the place synthetic intelligence and machine studying have gotten the norm within the monetary providers business. It’s not an exaggeration to say that the protection of depositors’ cash in Indian banks could be very dangerous. At any time when there may be a fear of a lender going dangerous, the regulator takes swift motion.

Explainer: How Silicon Valley Financial institution’s failure got here into limelight, which shook start-ups

At RBL Financial institution, when the regulator appointed an extra director on the board in December 2021 after CEO Vishwaveer Ahuja abruptly stop, it issued an announcement assuring the general public that the lender’s monetary well being was passable. Equally, final month when there was rising apprehension of an infection spreading within the banking system attributable to Adani Group, RBI issued an announcement assuring everybody that Indian banks are in a robust place.

Click Here To Join Our Telegram Channel

In case you have any issues or complaints concerning this text, please tell us and the article shall be eliminated quickly. 

Raise A Concern