‘Not entertaining’, SC refuses plea challenging Victoria Gowri’s appointment as Madras HC judge


NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court docket on Tuesday declined to entertain pleas difficult the appointment of Lakshmana Chandra Victoria Gowri as an extra decide of the Madras Excessive Court docket.

A bench comprising Justices Sanjiv Khanna and BR Gavai mentioned there’s a distinction between eligibility and suitability and on eligibility, there might be a problem however suitability? It added, “the court should not get into it…”

Senior advocate Raju Ramachandran, representing the petitioner, burdened that hate speech is one thing which runs antithesis to the Structure and such an oath will likely be an insincere oath and solely on paper. After listening to detailed arguments, the bench mentioned: “we are not entertaining the writ petition, reasons will follow”.

Through the listening to, the bench mentioned it can not direct the collegium to rethink its resolution on Victoria Gowri’s appointment as an extra decide of the Madras Excessive Court docket, and if any member of the collegium had any reservation on Gowri, they might have taken it up.

Ramachandran mentioned to see the ugly haste wherein the oath taking was notified and identified that the truth that this courtroom was listening to was delivered to the discover of the performing Chief Justice of Madras Excessive Court docket. He added that but they notified the appointment at 10.35 am, what’s the significance of 10.35? That this courtroom would resolve in 5 minutes?

Justice Gavai mentioned there are cases of further judges not being confirmed. Justice Khanna mentioned to imagine that the collegium has not taken this stuff into consideration, that might not be acceptable.

Senior advocate Anand Grover, representing the opposite petitioner, argued that they aren’t on the political beliefs of the particular person, reasonably the issue is together with her views expressed, that are so excessive, that they make it ex-facie evident that she is unfit to take oath as a decide.

The highest courtroom order got here on petitions filed by Anna Mathew, R. Vaigai and others difficult Gowri’s appointment as an extra decide of the Madras Excessive Court docket.

The Supreme Court docket collegium on January 17 had proposed the elevation of advocate Lekshmana Chandra Victoria Gowri as decide of the Madras Excessive Court docket.

A bunch of Madras Excessive Court docket attorneys have opposed Gowri’s proposed appointment after experiences emerged about her affiliation to the BJP and in addition sure alleged statements about Muslims and Christians, together with ‘Love Jihad’ and unlawful conversion.

Click Here To Join Our Telegram Channel

When you have any considerations or complaints concerning this text, please tell us and the article will likely be eliminated quickly. 

Raise A Concern